chpalmer wrote:
Quote:
wideband analog is best
There are some things where wideband analog is best.
Public Safety LMR is one of them... The human ear is still a better decoder than any chip in the radio. Having a radio that wont at least attempt to break static is unacceptable to many of us. If the radio is making some kind of noise the user can at least adjust his position to try and listen. With digital they may never know their getting a call to try and adjust... In fringe areas or in heavy multipath where the signal is questionable.
Digital hides interference from the user. Analog users can report that they are hearing a beat tone/other users on system/ect.
Yup, in addition, the more complicated it is, the easier it is for someone to screw it up. There's always brute force, which works better the more complicated the system is. Jam a digital signal and you'd never know you're being jammed....just wouldn't have any audio...
Jam a single analog channel and someone switches to an alternate freq.
Jam a control channel and....watch the radios go into failsoft one by one....and hope it's analog, as site trunking won't work if it uses the control channel if it loses its link to the other zones.
I can't believe that so called security experts are so concerned about people being able to listen in and not cloning radios....but have a chain link fence and a gate with a dollar store padlock to secure critical infrastructure... This tells me that it's not about security ay all.
But that's for another thread....
/vent